Anti-cap and trade forces (oil companies, coal companies, and their campaign contribution recipients) are publicizing a U.S. Department of Treasury report on the costs of cap and trade. Their right-wing spin interprets the total in "new taxes" (which are actually auction revenues from the government selling permits to corporations, then having them pass costs to consumers) of between $100 billion to $200 billion a year as meaning the cost per American household could be up to $1,761 a year.
The spin is wrong for several reasons. First, it depends what you do with the money. You can return the auction revenues back to people as a dividend or share. The costs are totally different depending on what you do with the money. Look up Dallas Burtraw's papers on the RFF website for more info.
Second, each state has unique carbon costs, depending on the amount of coal in its electricity mix, investment in energy efficiency, weather (too cold or too hot and you use more heat or AC), and more. So if you're in ND, WY, or WV, sure, you'll pay more. But if you're in Vermont, CA, or even Idaho, you won't pay that much. Now, maybe you want some redistribution payments to make it more fair, and that can be done through modifying the per capita dividend or share. But let's take the right wing spin with a large grain of salt (or chunk of smoggy coal-filled toxic pollution).
Showing posts with label cap trade global warming climate change carbon share. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cap trade global warming climate change carbon share. Show all posts
Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Monday, August 03, 2009
Senate can choose Dividends instead of House Climate Change Giveaway
The House strategy for Cap and Trade was 1) hand out allowances to utilities and other powerful lobbies, and 2) hope carbon costs will remain low (the so-called "postage stamp a day"). But many midwesterners, including North Dakotans Sen. Byron Dorgan and Rep. Earl Pomeroy are sceptical of the "postage stamp" strategy. High-coal states will face major costs, and the strategy puts supporters at risk in the 2010 or 2012 elections.
But the Senate still has time to choose an alternative strategy that sets aside Waxman and Pelosi's vision of realpolitik (that had almost everyone holding their noses by the end of House debate). An alternative strategy would be to level with the American people, tell them that costs might be high, but auction revenues will provide them with a dividend to help cover the costs. Perhaps Van Hollen's Cap and Dividend bill could be modified to limit the tradability of the auctioned permits, and then return the revenues to the people, bypassing the lobbyists and financial speculators.
But the Senate still has time to choose an alternative strategy that sets aside Waxman and Pelosi's vision of realpolitik (that had almost everyone holding their noses by the end of House debate). An alternative strategy would be to level with the American people, tell them that costs might be high, but auction revenues will provide them with a dividend to help cover the costs. Perhaps Van Hollen's Cap and Dividend bill could be modified to limit the tradability of the auctioned permits, and then return the revenues to the people, bypassing the lobbyists and financial speculators.
Friday, September 07, 2007
The new Carbon Share video
Carbon Share is a way to solve global warming by distributing emission rights to people and make polluters pay. Any cap and trade system should protect consumers, and not give windfall profits to polluters. Find out more at www.carbonshare.org.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)